Dispute Should this feedback Necrofaust left for roks1986 be removed? (1 Viewer)

[Teichou]

Username(s) of the accused

Necrofaust

This is an official feedback dispute, sponsored by the Ducat shop. After 7 days the votes will be tallied and the most popular judgement upheld. Official feedback rules are found here.

@roks1986 is disputing feedback left by @Necrofaust
Here is a link to the feedback. Note that this link may not work for non-moderators due to the user's privacy settings.

It reads:

Was pushing a sensitive sale (P99) when not adhering to the requested requirements, after me stating I didn’t feel comfortable doing a deal with someone with no feedback, persisted and was going to sell until a more suitable buyer came up.

Avoid.

If you are a moderator or staff please do not vote or comment.

 

[Xuande]

P99 players are so weird. Understandably so because a new low feedback P99 buyer could be a GM on a fishing expedition. I still hold that negative feedback should be reserved for onerous situations and that neutral feedback is more informational.

It's old feedback and they've gained positive feedback from many of the other sellers here. Prior to accepting roks as a customer (two years ago) I had to consider whether that feedback had any bearing on my ability to complete a transaction with them. It didn't and it hasn't.
roks and I have completed many deals since and has been nothing short of polite and fast throughout those interactions.

 

[blanco]

I would say after 3 years, getting verified + good feedback, and doing sales with some of the most trustworthy people on this site, we can remove this

Personally, I don't agree with negative feedback such as this (with no transaction taking place) that basically amounts to a seller, or buyer, feeling "uncomfortable" but alas it is the world we live in.

 

[Diamond Krono]

"Goodbye post" - Voted to remove feedback.