Dispute Should this feedback Lastat left for blaque88 be removed?

[Teichou]

Username(s) of the accused

Lastat

This is an official feedback dispute, sponsored by the Ducat shop. After 7 days the votes will be tallied and the most popular judgement upheld. Official feedback rules are found here.

@blaque88 is disputing feedback left by @Lastat
Here is a link to the feedback. Note that this link may not work for non-moderators due to the user's privacy settings.

It reads:

If you are a moderator or staff please do not vote or comment.

 

[Pory]

Isn't leaving negative feedback solely because another user left you negative feedback against the rules?

Or did I make that rule up?
I tried looking through some of the pinned posts but couldn't find anything.

 

[blanco]

Some context would be helpful @blaque88

Not that it matters, apparently we just vote yes on these. Missed the memo.

 

[Kenchi]

No was starting off strong at 1st but i went lurking and changed mine

 

[Pory]

This is why we need better rules for feedback. I personally feel this would be a fine neutral feedback, since there's no way to prove what's being said, but there definitely should be a record of it somewhere.

I would also like to know how quickly the acct was banned etc. If it was a month vs the next day, my opinion could change.

I wish people would put their opinions why they are voting one way or another, as discussion can often help other people understand a specific point of view.

Also, im 100% less likely to vote to remove feedback after noticing the OP left what seems to be retaliatory negative feedback on the accusers account also. I haven't voted no yet. Only becauss there's still time for information to come to light or people to delete their feedback. But that's def the way I'm leaning.

 

[blaque88]

Some context would be helpful @blaque88

Not that it matters, apparently we just vote yes on these. Missed the memo.

Sure.

User bought currency. Sale was smooth, evidenced privately in messages (with moderators now as a party), and user left feedback aligned with what you would expect from a great transaction.

Almost 1 month later, user gets banned on server. Comes back and leaves a 2nd feedback making a baseless allegation.

Hope this clears things up a bit for any who had questions.

Re. @Pory and my singular feedback left for the user, I went ahead and deleted it as I see your point.

 

[EcAnon]

NGL pretty sus you didn't get banned. The GM's there are extremely thorough with banning people. One time I got banned and every single account I ever accessed got banned. I'm also 100% sure there is at least 1 seller on here that is part of the GM crew. He sold to the same exact person that I did and all my accounts got banned but they didn't. They were unverified too which also doesn't look good for you. Who knows tho?

 

[Teichou]

It is a yes. So now we need to wait for @Redbot to do the thing.

 

[Redbot]

all set.

Isn't leaving negative feedback solely because another user left you negative feedback against the rules?

Or did I make that rule up?
I tried looking through some of the pinned posts but couldn't find anything.

the rules are here,

Terms and rules

You must agree to these terms and rules before using the site.

ectunnel.com