No tlp hate from me at least, I play on ragefire.
I played on Phini for all of about 1 hour and said fuck this. I don't need MQ2 to play EQ, but I'm not going to waste my time leveling (66% slower even), and be bored all day, when I can still get the same out of the TLPs on ragefire (or lockjawk, I suppose....).
I've used MQ2 since 2004. It's been apart of my Everquest experience for a long time. I used to warp, active hack, all of the stuff. It's fun, sure. It's like using gameshark on a game after you beat it. Just because you can. I laughed back in the day when EQMule (pretty sure he was part of that) would add anti-warping stuff, and what not. Good times. Those times are over, and unnecessary for the game. Most of them were purely for convince, that a lot are already added in the game now.
EQ is a fun relaxing game. Even all the drama on ragefire before the free transfers (lol now @ lockjaw problems) was still less than other games like WOW, where the entire game actually creates a toxic environment, just from a design level. Since the free transfers, Ragefire is just like any other server. Sure, you might have the occasional box crew (I run one), but most of them aren't douche-bags. Hell, even the big box crews often gave loot away to people standing around. The biggest problem is more so the 6 man mage groups (or, if we want to keep it based on reality, the 1 or 2 mages that would KS something from that solo player) that try to KS camps, and even those are gone for the most part.
IMO, if you want TLP like everyone wanted from the beginning, Ragefire or Lockjaw are going to be what you're after. Phini wont be fun for most people. You're still not going to get groups. There will still be boxers (I saw like 20+ 2 boxers just ii the hour or so I played...wtf, that was waayyyy more than on ragefire, ever), except those boxers are going to suck because it'll require someone to actually reach over to another computer to do anything. See ya tank, didn't reach over to my other computer fast enough to get that heal off! Peace!
- - - Updated - - -
You don't like remakes of Final fantasy games? I played them at release and loved most remakes. Even replayed Chrono Trigger on an EMU among others. How is that any different than TLP vs Live other than being an MMO.
TLP = rebuild of EQ with all the comforts of modern MMO's
How does anything that happens on TLP affect you if you don't play there. DBG doesn't give a shit. All it does is satisfy your need to get your opinion into someone elses experience.
Razkle, I answered your question
I'd give this guy a Thanks if I could.